In uncertain times, fundraising success hinges less on how often you ask—and more on how deeply you connect.
Donors today are navigating their own financial pressures and are becoming more selective about where they give. In this environment, the relationships you build between campaigns matter more than ever. At Inbloom, we’re seeing a consistent pattern among organizations navigating this cautious climate successfully: they lead with trust, not just transactions.
Here are four actionable ways to strengthen donor trust right now:
1. Treat Stewardship as Strategy
Donor relationships don’t begin or end with a gift. Thoughtful, consistent follow-up builds long-term loyalty. A well-timed thank-you, a short update, or a handwritten note reminds donors they’re part of your mission, not just funding it.
2. Be Honest About the Challenges
Donors don’t expect perfection; they expect transparency. Celebrate progress but also be open about what is hard. When you frame challenges as opportunities for impact, you invite donors into the problem-solving process rather than pushing them away.
3. Make It Personal (Without Overcomplicating It)
You don’t need a major gifts team to create meaningful touchpoints. A segmented email, a personalized subject line, or a brief voicemail can go a long way. These small, intentional efforts, done consistently, build trust at scale.
4. Lead with Purpose and Story
Now is the time to revisit your messaging. Are you speaking to what your donors care about most? Are your stories rooted in lived experience and real outcomes? Donors give to people and purpose, not just programs.
The Bottom Line: Relationships Over Campaigns
Donor fatigue is real, but often, it’s the result of organizations talking at their donors instead of engaging them. A relational approach is what sets resilient fundraisers apart in today’s climate. At Inbloom, we believe trust is the most valuable currency in any donor relationship, and we’re here to help you build it.
Submitted By: Mary Herzak | Inbloom COO & CMO | Connect w/ Mary
Need support with messaging, segmentation, or year-round stewardship strategies?
Let’s talk. We’d love to hear what you’re working on.
